Carmine's Pie House is the 2023 Award Winner as Best Pizza in Jacksonville, Presented by Travelers' Atlas®.
2677 Forbes Street, Jacksonville - Florida 32204 - USA
In Jacksonville, the winner of the Best Pizza offers a diverse menu that includes pizzas, appetizers, traditional Italian fare, and craft beers, all within an ambiance reminiscent of the 1980s. The decor features wall murals by local artists and a soundtrack of rock music. The menu presents a range of choices, from Jumbo Chicken Wings and Garlic Cheese Bread (available gluten-free) to Paninis like Capone's Chicago Beef Sub, with pizzas being the highlight.
Among the pizza selections in Carmine's Pie House, the Yorker stands out as a New York Thin and Crispy Pie, offered in a 14-inch size. This establishment is a spot for pizza and local rock fans. It accommodates both social gatherings or casual meals in a setting that celebrates the 80s' cultural vibe. To enhance the dining experience, Carmine's also features a selection of local craft beers, carefully chosen to complement the flavors of its pizzas and appetizers.
Ratings
4.5
4.5
Recognitions
Local's Favorite
Great Service
Contact
Hours
SUN 11AM - 9PM
MON 11AM - 9PM
TUE 11AM - 9PM
WED 11AM - 9PM
THU 11AM - 9PM
FRI 11AM - 10PM
SAT 11AM - 10PM
Reviews
767conniem
5 out of 5 been here twice, great pizza and staff, had Margherita pizza thin crust, wonderful! Had cheexy bread and Two other pizzas all are good
AlpayK8
One of the best pizza place in Jacksonville. Great place, friendly and family oriented atmosphere plus best Italian dishes as well as the mouth watering New York style pizza.
Jones_fromSouthGA
Came here with picky family members - and they loved it! Best pizza that I remember having. It was very busy but the waitstaff was attentive. Can’t wait to go back.
Reviews
.png){kind=small}
Drew B
Love this place. Its the closest to NY style comfort food I have experienced in Fl. Highly recommended...
Kacie B
THE BEST Chicago style pizza in Jax. It's a must go-to every time my parents come into town to visit. Chicago style with meatballs and ricotta never disappoints!
Marcy W
I love this place. The closest to NY pizza ‼
Managers and servers are really nice
It's a really cool little spot. Can even sit outside if you want
Reviews
Heather H
This place was super awesome! Super friendly staff and pizza slices as big as your head!! Pizza and cheese bread were delicious!! Would definitely recommend this place to pizza lovers!!
Shelly Whitt
Great crust and great sauce! That’s what makes a pizza . This place has it. My husband is from upstate and is 100% Italian so finding pizza to please his pallet is hard to find. Well not anymore..
A.
We went last weekend and got our first ever Chicago style pizza. As native New Yorkers we couldn’t believe how much we enjoyed it. We spent the week thinking about this pizza.